Host State, Victim State: Problematising the ‘Unable/Unwilling’ Test

The ‘unable or unwilling’ test allows a state to lawfully use force against non-state actors who are present in another state which is unable or unwilling to suppress the threat posed by the non-state actors. In this post, Ahmad Ammar and Arkaprava Dass seek to establish the test as fundamentally antithetical to Article 51 of the UN Charter pertaining to the use of force, and offer options to minimise collateral damage for both host and victim state. The article finds its premise in the Balakot Air Strikes of February 2019, wherein the Indian Air Force had targeted the training camps of a terror group based in Pakistan. Continue reading Host State, Victim State: Problematising the ‘Unable/Unwilling’ Test

Essar Steel Case: The ‘Upside-down’ of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code

In this post, Hansaja Pandya discusses the order of the NCLAT in the Essar Steel Case, and the potential dangers it has given rise to for the Indian debt market. The author highlights the fallacies present in the NCLAT order and emphasises upon the need for a balanced formula which does not discriminate against any creditor nor unduly favours any. Continue reading Essar Steel Case: The ‘Upside-down’ of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code

Application of the Limitation Act to Proceedings before Tribunals

In this post, Varun Rao seeks to rebut the non-applicability of the Limitation Act in tribunals. He puts forward a two-pronged argument, supported with case laws, revolving around the tribunals’ close nexus to courts themselves, and taking a liberal approach to the Limitation Act. Continue reading Application of the Limitation Act to Proceedings before Tribunals

Office of Public Prosecutor: A Much Needed Clarity

In this post the author seeks to discuss the pivotal role played by a Public Prosecutor in the criminal justice system. He further sheds light on the ambiguities in its definition and provides various guidelines to rectify the loopholes and protect the integrity of the office. Continue reading Office of Public Prosecutor: A Much Needed Clarity

Shreya Singhal case and its Enforceability: A Failed Attempt by the Supreme Court to Save Freedom of Speech and Expression

In the latest post, the authors examine how the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court have been flouted by authorities to make unlawful arrests under struck down laws, and illustrate it with the recent case of a BJP activist being arrested for sharing a morphed image of West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee on social media. They discuss the possible reasons behind such arrests and propose solutions to prevent such practices in future. Continue reading Shreya Singhal case and its Enforceability: A Failed Attempt by the Supreme Court to Save Freedom of Speech and Expression

Jet in the Tribunal: Viability of the Resolution for the Service Industry

In the latest post, the authors seek to discuss the sudden downfall of the debt-laden Jet Airways. They shed light on the current situation of the airline and the forthcoming opportunities and obstacles in its way to resume the aviation services. Continue reading Jet in the Tribunal: Viability of the Resolution for the Service Industry

The Right to Abort: An Argument for Autonomy

In the latest post, Akash attempts to analyse the debate surrounding women’s right to abort, takes in review the existing state of affairs in the United States with respect to existing laws placing restrictions on women’s choice, and propounds the argument of their autonomy. Continue reading The Right to Abort: An Argument for Autonomy

India has the Right under International Law to Sever Diplomatic Ties with Pakistan

In the latest post, Yash Vardhan Aggarwal throws light on how in the wake of the Pulwama terror attack, India’s next step should be to internationally isolate Pakistan as a state-sponsor for terrorism. He further elucidates how India now has to right under international law to sever diplomatic ties with Pakistan and impose economic sanctions. Continue reading India has the Right under International Law to Sever Diplomatic Ties with Pakistan